
<a name=1></a>ȱ<br/>
ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ<br/>¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱǯȱȱ<br/>ȱȱȱ<br/>
¢ȱŘşǰȱŘŖŖŝȱ<br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
ŝȬśŝŖŖȱ<br/>
   ǯǯȱ<br/>
şŝȬŝŞŖȱ<br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/><i>Pr</i><br/>
  <i>epared for Members and Committees of Congress <b>       </b></i><br/>
<hr/>
<a name=2></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
¢ȱ<br/>
The Speaker of the House of Representatives is widely viewed as symbolizing the power and <br/>authority of the House. The Speaker’s most prominent role is that of presiding officer of the <br/>House. In this capacity, the Speaker is empowered by House rules to administer proceedings on <br/>the House floor, including the power to recognize Members on the floor to speak or make <br/>motions and the power to appoint Members to conference committees. The Speaker also oversees <br/>much of the non-legislative business of the House, such as general control over the Hall of the <br/>House and the House side of the Capitol and service as chair of the House Office Building <br/>Commission. The Speaker’s role as “elect of the elect” in the House also places him or her in a <br/>highly visible position with the public. <br/>
The Speaker also serves not only as titular leader of the House but also as leader of the majority <br/>party conference. The Speaker is often responsible for airing and defending the majority party’s <br/>legislative agenda in the House. <br/>
The Speaker’s third distinct role is that of an elected Member of the House. Although elected as <br/>an officer of the House, the Speaker continues to be a Member as well. As such the Speaker <br/>enjoys the same rights, responsibilities, and privileges of all Representatives. However, the <br/>Speaker has traditionally refrained from debating or voting in most circumstances, and does not <br/>sit on any standing committee of the House. <br/>
 <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
<hr/>
<a name=3></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 1 <br/>
Selection of the Speaker .................................................................................................................. 1 <br/>
The Speaker as Leader of the House ............................................................................................... 3 <br/>
The Speaker as Party Leader ........................................................................................................... 4 <br/>
The Speaker as a Member of the House .......................................................................................... 7 <br/>
 <br/>
¡ȱ<br/>
Appendix A. Speakers of the House of Representatives, 1789-2007 .............................................. 9 <br/>
Appendix B. Select Bibliography.................................................................................................. 12 <br/>
 <br/>
ȱ<br/>
Author Contact Information .......................................................................................................... 13 <br/>
 <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
<hr/>
<a name=4></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
Article I, Section 2 of the Constitution states: “The House of Representatives shall chuse their <br/>Speaker and other Officers.”1 The position of Speaker combines several roles: the institutional <br/>role of presiding officer and administrative head of the House, the partisan role of leader of the <br/>majority party in the House, and the representative role of an elected Member of the House. As <br/>the “elect of the elect” the Speaker has perhaps the most visible job in Congress. By statute, the <br/>Speaker is also second in line, behind the Vice President, to succeed to the presidency.2 <br/>
The Constitution does not describe the office of the Speaker or its duties, nor was there any <br/>significant discussion of the office during the Constitutional Convention. The use of the title <br/>“Speaker” probably has its origins in the British House of Commons, where the presiding officer <br/>acted as the chamber’s spokesman to the Crown, but any assumptions the authors of the <br/>Constitution had for the office undoubtedly also drew upon their own experiences in colonial <br/>legislatures and the Continental Congress. There does not seem to have been any grand plan or <br/>specific expectation as to how the Founding Fathers envisioned the speakership. Rather, the <br/>speakership has been largely shaped by the various individuals who have held the post, the <br/>circumstances in which they have operated, formal obligations that have been assigned to the <br/>office by House rules and by statute, the character of the House as a political and constitutional <br/>institution, and traditions and customs that have evolved over time. <br/>
ȱȱȱřȱ<br/>
When the House of Representatives convenes at the beginning of a new Congress, its first order <br/>of business is to elect a Speaker. Because the House dissolves at the end of a Congress and must <br/>start anew at the beginning of each new Congress, the clerk of the House presides over the House <br/>under general parliamentary law until a Speaker is elected. For its first 50 years, the House <br/>elected the Speaker by ballot. In 1839, this method was changed to election by <i>vive voce</i>, <br/>meaning that each Member names aloud whom he or she favors for Speaker. Tellers then record <br/>the result. In modern practice, each party places the name of a single Member in nomination for <br/>the position, but otherwise virtually the same <i>vive voce</i> method is used to elect the Speaker. <br/>Because the election of the Speaker typically takes place before the House adopts its rules of <br/>procedure, the election process is defined by precedent and practice rather than by any formal <br/>rule. <br/>
                                                                 <br/>1 The other officers of the House are not specified in the Constitution. Currently, under House Rule II, the clerk, <br/>sergeant-at-arms, chief administrative officer, and chaplain are identified as officers to be elected by the House, <br/>although the rule also states that the clerk, sergeant-at-arms, and chief administrative officer may be removed either by <br/>the House or the Speaker. Rule II also identifies additional officers, the historian of the House, the general counsel, and <br/>the inspector general, to be appointed by the Speaker. <br/>2 The Presidential Succession Act of 1947 (P.L. 80-199, 61 Stat. 380) provides that if “there is neither a President nor <br/>Vice President to discharge the powers and duties of the office of the President, then the Speaker of the House of <br/>Representatives shall, upon his resignation as Speaker and as Representative in Congress, act as President.” To succeed <br/>to the presidency a Speaker would also need to qualify under the terms of Article II, Section 5 of the Constitution, <br/>which requires that the President be a “natural-born citizen,” at least 35 years of age, and a resident within the United <br/>States for 14 years. <br/>3 For more on elections of the Speaker, see CRS Report RL30857, <i>Speakers of the House: Elections, 1913-2007</i>, by <br/>Richard S. Beth and James V. Saturno. <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
ŗȱ<br/>
<hr/>
<a name=5></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
To be elected Speaker, a candidate must receive an absolute majority of the votes cast, which may <br/>be less than a majority of the full membership of the House because of vacancies, absentees, or <br/>Members voting “present.”4 Although the major parties nominate candidates for the position of <br/>Speaker, there is no limitation on whom Members may vote for.5 In fact, there is no requirement <br/>that the Speaker be a Member of the House.6 None of the other officers of the House is a Member. <br/>
If no candidate receives the requisite majority, the roll call is repeated until a Speaker is elected. <br/>Again, Members may continue to vote for any individual, and no restrictions, such as eliminating <br/>minority candidates or prohibiting new candidates from being named, are imposed. For example, <br/>at the beginning of the 34th Congress in 1855, 133 ballots over a period of two months were <br/>necessary to elect Nathaniel Banks of Massachusetts as Speaker.7 <br/>
The last occasion on which multiple ballots were required to elect a Speaker was in 1923. At the <br/>beginning of the 68th Congress, the nominees from both major parties initially failed to receive a <br/>majority of the votes because of votes cast for other candidates by Members from the Progressive <br/>Party and from the “progressive wing” of the Republican Party. After the Republican leadership <br/>agreed to accept a number of procedural reforms, the Progressives agreed to vote for the <br/>Republican candidate on the ninth ballot, making Frederick Gillett of Massachusetts the Speaker.8 <br/>
If a Speaker dies or resigns during a Congress, the House immediately elects a new Speaker. <br/>Although it was an earlier practice of the House to elect a new Speaker under these conditions by <br/>adopting a resolution to that effect, the modern practice is to use the same practice as employed at <br/>the beginning of a Congress. The most recent example of this occurred during the 101st Congress <br/>when Thomas Foley of Washington was elected Speaker following the resignation of Jim Wright <br/>of Texas.9 <br/>
In the 19th century, longevity of House service was not as important a criterion in selecting the <br/>Speaker as it is today. It was not unusual for a Member to be elected Speaker with only a few <br/>years service. From 1789 to 1899, the average length of House service before a Member was <br/>elected Speaker was 7.1 years. In fact, Henry Clay of Kentucky (in 1811) and William <br/>Pennington of New Jersey (in 1860) were each elected Speaker as freshmen (the first Speaker, <br/>Frederick A. Muhlenberg of Pennsylvania, was obviously a third, albeit special, case). <br/>
The 19 Speakers elected between 1899 (David B. Henderson) and 2007 (Nancy Pelosi) served an <br/>average of 22.9 years in the House prior to their first election as Speaker. The longest pre-<br/>speakership tenure in this period belonged to Jim Wright who served for 17 terms before being <br/>
                                                                 <br/>4 The controlling precedent dates to Mar. 18, 1879, when in response to an inquiry, the clerk, while presiding over the <br/>House, stated: “It requires a majority of those voting to elect a Speaker, as it does to pass a bill.” Asher Hinds, <i>Hinds’ <br/>Precedents of the House of Representatives of the United States</i> (Washington: GPO, 1907), vol. 1, sec. 216. (Hereafter <br/>cited as <i>Hinds’ Precedents</i>.) <br/>5 However, a provision was added (currently House Rule I, clause 9) at the start of the 104th Congress limiting a <br/>Speaker to service for four consecutive Congresses. <br/>6 For example, in the election of the Speaker at the beginning of the 105th Congress, two former Members of the House <br/>(Robert H. Michel and Robert Walker) each received one vote. <i>Congressional Record</i>, vol. 143, Jan. 7, 1997, p. 117. <br/>7 On the 133rd ballot, Nathaniel Banks received 103 votes while his four opponents received a total of 111. Since this <br/>was not a majority, the House subsequently adopted a resolution, by majority vote, confirming the election. <br/><i>Congressional Globe</i>, vol. 25, 34th Cong., 1st sess., Feb. 2, 1856, pp. 337-342. <br/>8 <i>Congressional Record</i>, vol. 65, Dec. 3-5, 1923. <br/>9 <i>Congressional Record</i>, vol. 135, June 6, 1989, p. 10800. <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
Řȱ<br/>
<hr/>
<a name=6></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
elected as Speaker. Sam Rayburn of Texas served longer as Speaker than any other Member: a <br/>tenure of 17 years (interrupted twice by Republican majorities). Thomas P. “Tip” O’Neill Jr. of <br/>Massachusetts holds the record for the longest continuous service as Speaker: 10 years. The <br/>record for the shortest tenure belongs to Theodore M. Pomeroy of New York who served one day. <br/>(<b>Appendix A</b> lists all the Speakers of the House as well as their party affiliations, home state, and <br/>their dates of service in that office.) <br/>
ȱȱȱȱȱȱ
ȱ<br/>
Although the office of the Speaker is mentioned in the Constitution, that document is silent on its <br/>duties. Today, the Speaker possesses substantial powers under House rules. Among the duties <br/>performed are <br/>
•  administering the oath of office to Members (the Act of 1789 (2 U.S.C. 25) <br/>
provides that, on the organization of the House, the oath shall be administered by <br/>any Member, traditionally the Member with the longest continuous service, to the <br/>Speaker and by the Speaker to the other Members); <br/>
•  calling the House to order (Rule I, clause 1); <br/>•  preserving order and decorum within the chamber and in the galleries (Rule I, <br/>
clause 2); <br/>
•  recognizing Members to speak and make motions (Rule XVII);10 <br/>•  deciding points of order (Rule I, clause 5); <br/>•  counting a quorum (Rule XX, clause 7(c)); <br/>•  presenting the pending business to the House for a vote (Rule I, clause 6); <br/>•  appointing Speakers <i>pro tempore</i> (Rule I, clause 8) and chairs of the Committee <br/>
of the Whole (Rule XVIII, clause 1);11 <br/>
•  certifying various actions of the House, including signing all acts and joint <br/>
resolutions, writs, warrants, and subpoenas of (or issued to) the House (Rule I, <br/>clause 4);12 <br/>
•  appointing select and conference committees (Rule I, clause 11); <br/>
                                                                 <br/>10 This provision is augmented by the provision in Rule XVI, clause 1, which states that the Speaker shall not entertain <br/>any dilatory motions. <br/>11 By tradition, the Speaker does not preside over the Committee of the Whole, but instead names a party colleague as <br/>chair. According to historian DeAlva Stanwood Alexander, this tradition has its roots in Stuart England when conflicts <br/>over taxation arrayed the Crown against the Commons, and suspicion assumed the Speaker to be a tale bearer to the <br/>King. To avoid the Speaker’s espionage Commons met in secret, electing a chairman in whom it had confidence. Even <br/>after any need for secrecy in its proceedings had passed, Commons continued to require that the Speaker withdraw <br/>whenever the Committee of the Whole convened. DeAlva Stanwood Alexander, <i>History and Procedure of the House of <br/>Representatives</i> (New York: Houghton Mifflin, 1916), pp. 257-258. The American tradition does not require the <br/>Speaker to withdraw from the deliberations of the Committee of the Whole, only that he not chair it. <br/>12 Responses to subpoenas are also governed under Rule VIII. <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
řȱ<br/>
<hr/>
<a name=7></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
•  appointing certain House officers (such as the inspector general under Rule II, <br/>
clause 6, the historian of the House under Rule II, clause 7, and the general <br/>counsel under Rule II, clause 8); <br/>
•  referring measures to committee(s) (Rule XII, clause 2); and <br/>•  examining and approving the <i>Journal</i> of the proceedings of the previous day’s <br/>
session (Rule I, clause 1). <br/>
The Speaker’s powers offer him or her considerable latitude to exercise discretion. Under most <br/>circumstances, the Speaker has the authority to ask Members who seek recognition, “For what <br/>purpose does the gentleman (or gentlelady) rise?” The Speaker may then decide whether or not to <br/>recognize that Member for the specific reason given. In this way the Speaker is able to assert <br/>control over what motions may be made and therefore what measures will be considered and the <br/>general flow of House floor proceedings. House Rule XV, clause 1 allows the Speaker to <br/>entertain motions to suspend the rules on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays, as well as during <br/>the last six days of a session. Discretion over who may be recognized to make such motions gives <br/>the Speaker virtually complete control over the suspension process. <br/>
The institutional role of the Speaker also extends beyond the duty to preside over the House. The <br/>Speaker also exercises general control over the Hall of the House and the House side of the <br/>Capitol (Rule I, clause 3), and serves as the chair of the House Office Building Commission. The <br/>Speaker frequently is authorized in statute to appoint Members to various boards and <br/>commissions, and it is typically the Speaker who is the formal recipient of reports or other <br/>communications from the President, government agencies, boards, and commissions. <br/>
The role of the Speaker also extends to the requirement in House Rule V, clause 1 that he or she <br/>administer a system for audio and video broadcasting of the proceedings of the House. Rule I, <br/>clause 13 provides for the Speaker, in consultation with the minority leader, to devise a system of <br/>drug testing in the House. <br/>
Finally, although it is not prescribed in any formal way, the elevated profile of the office of the <br/>Speaker often means he must take a leading role in negotiations with the Senate or President. <br/>
ȱȱȱ¢ȱȱ<br/>
Under both Republican and Democratic majorities, Speakers have played similar roles as leader <br/>of their parties. A Speaker’s role as leader of the majority party is manifested in two ways: within <br/>the party conference or caucus and on the House floor. <br/>
Under the rules of the House Democratic Caucus, the Speaker recommends to the Caucus <br/>nominees for officers of the House. The Speaker’s prominence within the Caucus is reinforced <br/>because she chairs the Steering and Policy Committee, and appoints two co-chairs, two vice-<br/>chairs, and up to 15 of its Members. In addition, the Speaker is empowered to appoint one <br/>Member to the House Budget Committee, as well as make appointments to joint and select <br/>committees, and various boards and commissions, giving due consideration to spreading the <br/>workload among qualified and interested Democrats. She nominates the Democratic membership <br/>on the Committees on Rules and House Administration, and recommends to the Caucus a <br/>nominee for chair of these committees. If a nominee is rejected, the Speaker may make another <br/>nomination until the position is filled. <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
Śȱ<br/>
<hr/>
<a name=8></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
Within the Democratic Party, the Speaker serves as a member of the Democratic Congressional <br/>Campaign Committee (DCCC) and also nominates the DCCC chair. <br/>
Previously, within the Republican Party conference, the Speaker acted as the chairman of the <br/>party’s Steering Committee, and thus plays a major part in the committee assignment process <br/>because Members are nominated to serve on or chair a committee by the Steering Committee. <br/>These nominations are subject to approval by the full party conference, and subsequently by the <br/>House. In the 104th Congress, it appears that the Speaker exerted further influence in the process <br/>of nominating Members to chair committees by naming a slate of candidates before the Steering <br/>Committee had been formed. Although the Speaker’s choices required the approval of the <br/>Steering Committee before they were placed before the full conference, his influence was <br/>reported to have exceeded that of recent previous Speakers.13 <br/>
In addition, the Speaker was empowered to make nominations directly for the Republican <br/>Conference’s consideration for membership (including chairs) on the Rules Committee and the <br/>House Administration Committee, as well as the chair and one Member (to serve as the second <br/>ranking Republican) on the Budget Committee. <br/>
House Republican Conference rules also provided for the Speaker to serve on the National <br/>Republican Congressional Committee. Because the Speaker’s role as leader of the majority party <br/>in the House is sometimes at odds with his role as presiding officer of the chamber, House <br/>Republican Conference rules stated that: <br/>
A Member of the elected or designated Republican Leadership has an obligation, to the best <br/>of his/her ability, to support positions adopted by the Conference, and the resources of the <br/>Leadership shall be utilized to support that position. <br/>
The success of every person to hold the Speaker’s office since the late 20th century has been <br/>judged, at least in part, on the basis of their ability to use personal prestige, and the powers of <br/>persuasion and bargaining to enunciate and advance their party’s vision and legislative agenda, as <br/>well as work to ensure majority control of the House. To accomplish these objectives modern <br/>Speakers have used varying personal styles and engaged in a variety of activities, not just in <br/>Congress or their party conference, but outside as well.14 For example, they publicize their party’s <br/>policies and achievements (by giving speeches, appearing on radio and television, holding press <br/>conferences, etc.); assist party members who are seeking reelection; consult with Presidents about <br/>both Administration and congressional agendas and goals; and, when the majority in the House is <br/>not the same party as the President, they act as a spokesman for the loyal opposition. In the words <br/>of one commentator: <br/>
To an increasing degree, the way for a Speaker to win support among colleagues is to <br/>influence public opinion ... [A] House leader now needs some credibility outside the <br/>institution in order to win on the inside.15 <br/>
                                                                 <br/>13 Karen Foerstel, “House Chairmen: Gingrich Flexes His Power in Picking Panel Chiefs,” <i>Congressional Quarterly <br/>Weekly Report</i>, vol. 52, Nov. 19, 1994, p. 3326. <br/>14 Jackie Koszczuk, “Master of the Mechanics Has Kept the House Running,” <i>Congressional Quarterly Weekly Report</i>, <br/>vol. 57, Dec. 11, 1999, p. 2960. <br/>15 Alan Ehrenhalt, “Speaker’s Job Transformed Under O’Neill,” <i>Congressional Quarterly Weekly Report</i>, vol. 43, June <br/>22, 1985, p. 1247. <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
śȱ<br/>
<hr/>
<a name=9></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
Bringing coherence and efficiency to a decentralized and individualistic legislative body requires <br/>a Speaker to use the entire range of tangible and intangible rewards that can be bestowed or <br/>withheld. In an interview, Speaker O’Neill once described how he wielded these various minor <br/>powers by saying: <br/>
You know, you ask me what are my powers and my authorities around here? The power to <br/>recognize on the floor; little odds and ends—like men get pride out of the prestige of <br/>handling the Committee of the Whole, being named Speaker for the day.... [T]here is a <br/>certain aura and respect that goes with the Speaker’s office. He does have the power to pick <br/>up the telephone and call people. And Members oftentimes like to bring their local political <br/>leaders or a couple of mayors. And oftentimes they have problems from their area and they <br/>need aid and assistance.... We’re happy to try to open the door for them, having been in the <br/>town for so many years and knowing so many people. We do know where a lot of bodies are <br/>and we do know how to advise people.16 <br/>
The power to schedule legislation for floor consideration can be used in ways that reflect both <br/>institutional and partisan considerations. The Speaker is charged with ensuring that the House <br/>processes its fundamental annual workload, but determining what, when, and in which order a <br/>measure reaches the floor can help determine its fate. A week’s delay in scheduling a <br/>controversial bill may work to enhance or minimize its chances for passage. According to <br/>Speaker O’Neill, it was one of his most important powers because “if [a Speaker] doesn’t want a <br/>certain bill to come up, it usually doesn’t.”17 <br/>
Similarly, the Speaker’s authority to appoint conferees can be a powerful tool for influencing the <br/>final provisions of a bill. The Members appointed represent a complex balance of support for <br/>House, committee, and party positions as determined by the Speaker, and are not subject to <br/>challenge. <br/>
Modern Speakers have also frequently had to act as mediators of conflicts within their parties. As <br/>one leader put it, this involves: <br/>
Trying to mollify members who are angry with other members, trying to keep dangerous rifts <br/>from developing within the party. Sometimes getting people together of opposite viewpoints <br/>and letting them talk their problems out in a way that lets each understand that the other has a <br/>problem. Sometimes you can come to a compromise.18 <br/>
Balancing parliamentary and partisan roles is not always easily accomplished. At the start of the <br/>20th century, historian Mary Follett assessed this conundrum by writing: <br/>
The Speaker ... is not only allowed, but expected to use his position to advance party <br/>interests. It must not be supposed, however, that this implies gross partisanship on the part of <br/>our Speakers. They neither attempt to use every inch of power to be conjured out of the rules, <br/>nor guide the House entirely from party motives. Their office has on the whole been <br/>administered with justness and fairness ...19 <br/>
                                                                 <br/>16 Michael J. Malbin, “House Democrats Are Playing With a Strong Leadership Lineup,” <i>National Journal</i>, vol. 9, June <br/>18, 1977, p. 942. <br/>17 Thomas P. O’Neill Jr., <i>Man of the House</i> (New York: Random House, 1987), p. 273. <br/>18 The unidentified leader was quoted in Barbara Sinclair, <i>Majority Leadership in the U.S. House</i> (Baltimore: Johns <br/>Hopkins University Press, 1983), p. 38. <br/>19 Mary P. Follett, <i>The Speaker of the House of Representatives</i> (New York: Longmans Green, 1902), p. 300. <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
Ŝȱ<br/>
<hr/>
<a name=10></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
Another assessment states that: <br/>
Tradition and unwritten law require that the Speaker apply the rules of the House <br/>consistently, yet in the twilight zone a large area exists where he may exercise great <br/>discrimination and where he has many opportunities to apply the rules to his party’s <br/>advantage.20 <br/>
ȱȱȱȱȱȱȱ
ȱ<br/>
Although elected as an officer of the House, the Speaker continues to be a Member of the House <br/>as well. Accordingly, the Speaker continues to have the same rights, responsibilities, and <br/>privileges as all Members. However, because of the Speaker’s position as leader, it may be <br/>notable or even controversial when he or she exercises the powers granted to other Members, <br/>such as debating, voting, and sitting as a member of a standing committee of the House. <br/>
Under the principles articulated in <i>Jefferson’s Manual</i>,21 the Speaker is typically only heard on <br/>matters of order, and it is highly irregular to speak on any other matter while presiding. The <br/>Speaker, however, may speak from the floor (as would any other Member), and the precedents of <br/>the House include examples of the Speaker leaving the chair to speak from the well, make <br/>motions22 or debate a point of order.23 However, in most periods in the history of the House these <br/>privileges were infrequently exercised. <br/>
Jonathan Dayton of New Jersey was the first Speaker to speak out on a matter in Committee of <br/>the Whole (during the Fourth Congress), and it was not until Henry Clay of Kentucky became <br/>Speaker that this practice became generally accepted. As late as 1850, Chauncy Cleveland of <br/>Connecticut, then a Member of the House, questioned whether it would: <br/>
be right or just by the power of party to place a man in the Speaker’s chair, and then compel <br/>him to use the influence of the chair when he had defined his position.... It was utterly <br/>impossible that the Speaker, after having taken his side upon the floor, could go back to the <br/>chair, and award the floor with the same impartiality as if he had never spoken.24 <br/>
Even today it is not commonplace for the Speaker to participate in debate on the floor, although <br/>the Speaker may do so when he or she feels it necessary to highlight or rally support for the <br/>majority party’s agenda.25 <br/>
                                                                 <br/>20 Floyd M. Riddick, <i>The United States Congress: Organization and Procedure</i> (Washington: National Capitol <br/>Publishers, 1949), p. 67. <br/>21 Prepared by Thomas Jefferson while serving as Vice President (and President of the Senate), the Manual was <br/>adopted as a part of House rules beginning in 1837 to the extent that it is applicable and “not inconsistent with” the <br/>standing rules of the House (Rule XXVIII). <br/>22 On Apr. 4, 1864, Speaker Schuyler Colfax of Indiana came down from the chair to move a resolution to expel <br/>Representative Alexander Long of Ohio. He justified his action on the basis of Henry Clay’s frequent speeches from <br/>the floor while Speaker, but, according to Asher Hinds, Colfax evidently “confused” Clay’s actions in Committee of <br/>the Whole with participation during sessions of the House itself. See <i>Hinds’ Precedents</i>, vol. 2, sec. 1367 and footnote. <br/>23 Ibid., vol. 5, sec. 1607. <br/>24 <i>Congressional Globe</i>, vol. 21, 31st Cong., 1st sess., Jan. 14, 1850, p. 144. <br/>25 One such example occurred when Speaker Newt Gingrich claimed time in opposition to a motion to recommit the <br/>Tax Relief Act of 1997. See the <i>Congressional Record</i>, vol. 143, June 26, 1997, p. 12827. <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
ŝȱ<br/>
<hr/>
<a name=11></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
The right of the Speaker to vote has also evolved over time. The first rules of the House provided: <br/>
In all cases of ballot by the House, the Speaker shall vote; in other cases he shall not vote, <br/>unless the House be equally divided, or unless his vote, if given to the minority, will make <br/>the division equal, and in case of such equal division, the question shall be lost.26 <br/>
The Speaker was thus prevented from voting on legislative matters, although the precedents of <br/>the House record several examples of Speakers voting contrary to this rule.27 The Speaker was <br/>allowed to vote in Committee of the Whole, but most early Speakers apparently refrained from <br/>this practice as well. At least twice (in 1833 and 1837) the House debated proposals to compel the <br/>Speaker to vote on all questions, but these proposals were defeated.28 It was not until 1850 that <br/>the rule was amended to allow the Speaker to vote at his discretion, and the modern form of the <br/>rule was not adopted until 1880. Rule I, clause 7 currently reads: <br/>
The Speaker is not required to vote in ordinary legislative proceedings, except when his vote <br/>would be decisive or when the House is engaged in voting by ballot. <br/>
Unlike other Representatives, the Speaker does not sit on any standing committees of the <br/>House.29 This was not always the case. The Rules Committee was for many years a select <br/>committee authorized to report a system of rules at the beginning of a Congress, and later also to <br/>report from “time to time.” Beginning in 1858, and continuing after the Rules Committee was <br/>made a standing committee of the House in 1880, the Speaker served as chairman. This practice <br/>continued through 1910 when the House adopted a rule prohibiting the Speaker from sitting on <br/>the Rules Committee.30 The formal prohibition was removed from House rules by the Legislative <br/>Reorganization Act of 1946,31 but the tradition has continued. Today, the Speaker does not sit on <br/>the Rules Committee, but does nominate the majority members in the party conference, <br/>effectively making the Rules Committee an integral part of the leadership structure. <br/>
                                                                 <br/>26 <i>Annals of Congress</i>, vol. 1, 1st Cong., 1st sess., Apr. 7, 1789, p. 99. The House customarily uses balloting only for the <br/>election of its officers, not for resolving legislative questions. <br/>27 <i>Hinds’ Precedents</i>, vol. 5, secs. 5966-5967. <br/>28 Ibid., vol. 5, sec. 5964. <br/>29 However, the Speaker is designated as an ex officio member of the Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence <br/>under House Rule X, clause 11(a)(2). <br/>30 This restriction was adopted as a part of the so-called revolt against Speaker Joseph Cannon of Illinois at the <br/>beginning of the 61st Congress. See the <i>Congressional Record</i>, vol. 45, Mar. 15-19, 1910. <br/>31 P.L. 79-601, 60 Stat. 812. <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
Şȱ<br/>
<hr/>
<a name=12></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
¡ȱǯ<b> </b>ȱȱȱ
ȱȱ<br/>ǰȱŗŝŞşȬŘŖŖŝȱ<br/>
Speaker Party/State <br/>
Congress  Dates <br/>
1st <br/>
Apr. 1, 1789-Mar. 3, 1791 <br/>
Frederick A.C. Muhlenberg <br/>
[NKPA] - PA <br/>
3rd <br/>
Dec. 2, 1793-Mar. 3, 1795 <br/>
Jonathan Trumbull <br/>
[NKPA] - CT <br/>
2nd <br/>
Oct. 24, 1791-Mar. 3, 1793 <br/>
Jonathan Dayton <br/>
[NKPA] - NJ <br/>
4th-5th <br/>
Dec. 7, 1795-Mar. 3, 1799 <br/>
Theodore Sedgwick <br/>
[NKPA] - MA <br/>
6th <br/>
Dec. 2, 1799-Mar. 3, 1801 <br/>
Nathaniel Macon <br/>
[NKPA] - NC <br/>
7th-9th <br/>
Dec. 7, 1801-Mar. 3, 1807 <br/>
Joseph B. Varnum <br/>
[NKPA] - MA <br/>
10th-11th <br/>
Oct. 26, 1807-Mar. 3, 1811 <br/>
12th-13th <br/>
Nov. 4, 1811-Jan. 19, 1814a <br/>
Henry Clay <br/>
R (DR) - KY <br/>
14th-16th <br/>
Dec. 4, 1815-Oct. 28, 1820b <br/>
18th <br/>
Dec. 3, 1823-Mar. 6, 1825c <br/>
Langdon Cheves <br/>
R (DR) - SC <br/>
13th <br/>
Jan. 19, 1814-Mar. 3, 1815 <br/>
16th <br/>
Nov. 15, 1820-Mar. 3, 1821 <br/>
John W. Taylor <br/>
R (DR) - NY <br/>
19th <br/>
Dec. 5, 1825-Mar. 3, 1827 <br/>
Philip Barbour <br/>
R (DR) - VA <br/>
17th <br/>
Dec. 4, 1821-Mar. 3, 1823 <br/>
[NKPA] - VA <br/>
20th <br/>
Dec. 3, 1827-Mar. 3, 1829 <br/>
Andrew Stevenson <br/>
Jacksonian - VA <br/>
21st-23rd <br/>
Dec. 7, 1829-June 2, 1834d <br/>
John Bell <br/>
[NKPA] - TN <br/>
23rd <br/>
June 2, 1834-Mar. 3, 1835 <br/>
James K. Polk <br/>
Jacksonian - TN <br/>
24th-25th <br/>
Dec. 7, 1835-Mar. 3, 1839 <br/>
Robert M.T. Hunter <br/>
W - VA <br/>
26th <br/>
Dec. 16, 1839-Mar. 3, 1841 <br/>
John White <br/>
W - KY <br/>
27th <br/>
May 31, 1841-Mar. 3, 1843 <br/>
John W. Jones <br/>
D - VA <br/>
28th <br/>
Dec. 4, 1843-Mar. 3, 1845 <br/>
John W. Davis <br/>
D - IN <br/>
29th <br/>
Dec. 1, 1845-Mar. 3, 1847 <br/>
Robert C. Winthrop <br/>
W - MA <br/>
30th <br/>
Dec. 6, 1847-Mar. 3, 1849 <br/>
Howell Cobb <br/>
D - GA <br/>
31st <br/>
Dec. 22, 1849-Mar. 3, 1851 <br/>
Linn Boyd <br/>
D - KY <br/>
32nd-33rd <br/>
Dec. 1, 1851-Mar. 3, 1855 <br/>
Nathaniel P. Banks <br/>
American Party - MAe 34th <br/>
Feb. 2, 1856-Mar. 3, 1857 <br/>
James L. Orr <br/>
D - SC <br/>
35th <br/>
Dec. 7, 1857-Mar. 3, 1859 <br/>
William Pennington <br/>
R - NJ <br/>
36th <br/>
Feb. 1, 1860-Mar. 3, 1861 <br/>
Galusha A. Grow <br/>
R - PA <br/>
37th <br/>
July 4, 1861-Mar. 3, 1863 <br/>
Schuyler Colfax <br/>
R - IN <br/>
38th-40th <br/>
Dec. 7, 1863-Mar. 3, 1869f <br/>
Theodore M. Pomeroy <br/>
R - NY <br/>
40th <br/>
Mar. 3, 1869g <br/>
James G. Blaine <br/>
R - ME <br/>
41st-43rd <br/>
Mar. 4, 1869-Mar. 3, 1875 <br/>
Michael C. Kerr <br/>
D - IN <br/>
44th <br/>
Dec. 6, 1875-Aug. 19, 1876h <br/>
Samuel J. Randall <br/>
D - PA <br/>
44th-46th <br/>
Dec. 4, 1876-Mar. 3, 1881 <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
şȱ<br/>
<hr/>
<a name=13></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
Speaker Party/State <br/>
Congress  Dates <br/>
J. Warren Keifer <br/>
R - OH <br/>
47th <br/>
Dec. 5, 1881-Mar. 3, 1883 <br/>
John G. Carlisle <br/>
D - KY <br/>
48th-50th <br/>
Dec. 3, 1883-Mar. 3, 1889 <br/>
51st <br/>
Dec. 2, 1889-Mar. 3, 1891 <br/>
Thomas B. Reed <br/>
R - ME <br/>
54th-55th <br/>
Dec. 2, 1895-Mar. 3, 1899 <br/>
Charles F. Crisp <br/>
D - GA <br/>
52nd-53rd <br/>
Dec. 7, 1891-Mar. 3, 1895 <br/>
David B. Henderson <br/>
R - IA <br/>
56th-57th <br/>
Dec. 4, 1899-Mar. 3, 1903 <br/>
Joseph G. Cannon <br/>
R - IL <br/>
58th-61st <br/>
Nov. 9, 1903-Mar. 3, 1911 <br/>
James B. (Champ) Clark <br/>
D - MO <br/>
62nd-65th <br/>
Apr. 4, 1911-Mar. 3, 1919 <br/>
Frederick H. Gillett <br/>
R - MA <br/>
66th-68th <br/>
May 19, 1919-Mar. 3, 1925 <br/>
Nicholas Longworth <br/>
R - OH <br/>
69th-71st <br/>
Dec. 7, 1925Mar. 3, 1931 <br/>
John Nance Garner <br/>
D - TX <br/>
72nd <br/>
Dec. 7, 1931Mar. 3, 1933 <br/>
Henry T. Rainey <br/>
D - IL <br/>
73rd <br/>
Mar. 9, 1933-Aug. 19, 1934i <br/>
Joseph W. Byrns <br/>
D - TN <br/>
74th <br/>
Jan. 3, 1935-June 4, 1936j <br/>
William B. Bankhead <br/>
D - AL <br/>
74th-76th <br/>
June 4, 1936-Sept. 15, 1940k <br/>
76th-79th <br/>
Sept. 16, 1940-Jan. 3, 1947 <br/>
Sam T. Rayburn <br/>
D - TX <br/>
81st-82nd <br/>
Jan. 3, 1949-Jan. 3, 1953 <br/>
84th-87th <br/>
Jan. 5, 1955-Nov. 16, 1961l <br/>
80th <br/>
Jan. 3, 1947-Jan. 3, 1949 <br/>
Joseph W. Martin, Jr. <br/>
R - MA <br/>
83rd <br/>
Jan. 3, 1953-Jan. 3, 1955 <br/>
John W. McCormack <br/>
D - MA <br/>
87th-91st <br/>
Jan. 10, 1962-Jan. 3, 1971 <br/>
Carl B. Albert <br/>
D - OK <br/>
92nd-94th <br/>
Jan. 21, 1971-Jan. 3, 1977 <br/>
Thomas P. O’Neill Jr. <br/>
D - MA <br/>
95th-99th <br/>
Jan. 4, 1977-Jan. 3, 1987 <br/>
James C. Wright Jr. <br/>
D - TX <br/>
100th-101st <br/>
Jan. 6, 1987-June 6, 1989m <br/>
Thomas S. Foley <br/>
D - WA <br/>
101st-103rd <br/>
June 6, 1989-Jan. 3, 1995 <br/>
Newt Gingrich <br/>
R - GA <br/>
104th-105th <br/>
Jan. 4, 1995- Jan. 3, 1999 <br/>
J. Dennis Hastert <br/>
R - IL <br/>
106th-109th <br/>
Jan. 3, 1999- Jan. 4, 2007 <br/>
Nancy Pelosi <br/>
D - CA <br/>
110th- <br/>
Jan. 4, 2007 - <br/>
Notes: Party affiliations are indicated by initials: <br/>[NKPA] - No Known Party Affiliation <br/>R (DR) - Republican or Democratic-Republican Party (the Jeffersonian precursor of the Democratic Party) <br/>W - Whig Party <br/>D - Democratic Party <br/>R - Republican Party <br/>a.  Resigned from office, January 19, 1814, to serve on the negotiating team that produced the Treaty of Ghent, <br/>
ending the War of 1812. <br/>
b.  Resigned from the speakership, October 28, 1820. <br/>c.  Resigned from office, March 6, 1825, to serve as Secretary of State. <br/>d.  Resigned from office, June 2, 1834. <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
ŗŖȱ<br/>
<hr/>
<a name=14></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
e.  Speaker Banks served in the House three separate times under three different party designations. In the <br/>
34th Congress, he served as a member of the American Party. <br/>
f.  Resigned from office, March 3, 1869, to serve as Vice President. <br/>g.  Elected Speaker, March 3, 1869, and served one day. <br/>h.  Died in office, August 19, 1876. <br/>i.  Died in office, August 19, 1934. <br/>j.  Died in office, June 4, 1936. <br/>k.  Died in office, September 15, 1940. <br/>l.  Died in office, November 16, 1961. <br/>m.  Speaker Wright resigned the speakership on June 6, 1989, and subsequently resigned from the House on <br/>
June 30, 1989. <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
ŗŗȱ<br/>
<hr/>
<a name=15></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
¡ȱǯ<b> </b>ȱ¢ȱ<br/>
Albert, Carl Bert. <i>Little Giant: The Life and Times of Speaker Carl Albert</i>. Norman: University of <br/>
Oklahoma Press, 1990. <br/>
Bentley, Judith. <i>Speakers of the House</i>. New York: Franklin Watts Inc., 1994. <br/>
Biggs, Jeffrey R. <i>Honor in the House: Speaker Tom Foley</i>. Pullman: University of Washington <br/>
Press, 1999. <br/>
Clancy, Paul R. <i>Tip, A Biography of Thomas P. O’Neill, Speaker of the House</i>. New York: <br/>
Macmillan, 1980. <br/>
Cheney, Richard B. and Lynne V. Cheney. <i>Kings of the Hill: Power and Personality in the House </i><br/>
<i>of Representatives</i>. New York: Continuum, 1983. <br/>
Chiu, Chang-wei. <i>The Speaker of the House of Representatives Since 1896</i>. New York: Columbia <br/>
University Press, 1928; reprint edition New York: AMS Press, 1968. <br/>
Cooper, Joseph and David W. Brady. “Institutional Context and Leadership Style: The House <br/>
From Cannon to Rayburn,” <i>American Political Science Review</i>, vol. 75 (June 1981). <br/>
Davidson, Roger H., Susan Webb Hammond, and Raymond Smock. <i>Masters of the House: </i><br/>
<i>Congressional Leadership Over Two Centuries</i>. Boulder, CO: West Press, 1998. <br/>
Follett, Mary P. <i>The Speaker of the House of Representatives</i>. New York: Longmans Green, 1902; <br/>
reprint edition New York: Burt Franklin, 1974. <br/>
Fuller, Hubert Bruce. <i>The Speaker of the House</i>. Boston: Little Brown, 1909; reprint edition New <br/>
York: Arno Press, 1974. <br/>
Harris, Douglas B. “The Rise of the Public Speakership,” <i>Political Science Quarterly</i>, vol. 113 <br/>
(summer 1998). <br/>
Hinds, Asher C. “The Speaker of the House of Representatives: Origin of the Office, Its Duties <br/>
and Powers,” <i>American Political Science Review</i>, vol. 3 (May 1909). <br/>
Hitchner, Dell G. “The Speaker of the House of Representatives,” <i>Parliamentary Affairs</i>, vol. 13 <br/>
(spring 1960). <br/>
Kennon, Donald R., ed. <i>The Speakers of the U.S. House of Representatives: A Bibliography, </i><br/>
<i>1789-1984</i>. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1986. <br/>
Moser, Charles A. <i>The Speaker and the House: Coalitions and Power in the United States House </i><br/>
<i>of Representatives</i>. Washington: Free Congress Research and Education Foundation, 1979. <br/>
O’Neill, Thomas P. Jr. <i>Man of the House</i>. New York: Random House, 1987. <br/>
Peters, Ronald M. <i>The American Speakership: The Office in Historical Perspective (2nd ed.)</i>. <br/>
Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1997. <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
ŗŘȱ<br/>
<hr/>
<a name=16></a>ȱȱȱȱ
Ǳȱ
ȱǰȱ¢ȱǰȱȱȱ<br/>
ȱ<br/>
——, ed. <i>The Speaker: Leadership in the U.S. House of Representatives</i>. Washington: <br/>
Congressional Quarterly, 1995. <br/>
Peabody, Robert L. <i>Leadership in Congress: Stability, Succession, and Change</i>. Boston: Little <br/>
Brown, 1976. <br/>
Ripley, Randall B. <i>Party Leaders in the House of Representatives</i>. Washington: Brookings <br/>
Institution, 1967. <br/>
Rohde, David W. <i>Parties and Leaders in the Postreform House</i>. Chicago: University of Chicago <br/>
Press, 1991. <br/>
Sinclair, Barbara. <i>Majority Leadership in the U.S. House</i>. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University <br/>
Press, 1983. <br/>
——. <i>Legislators, Leaders, and Lawmaking: The U.S. House of Representatives in the Postreform </i><br/>
<i>Era</i>. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1995. <br/>
Smith, Steven S. “O’Neill’s Legacy for the House,” <i>Brookings Review</i>, v. 5 (winter 1987). <br/>
Smith, William Henry. <i>Speakers of the House of Representatives of the United States</i>. New York: <br/>
AMS Press, 1971. <br/>
 <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/> <br/>James V. Saturno <br/>
   <br/>
Section Research Manager <br/>jsaturno@crs.loc.gov, 7-2381 <br/>
 <br/>
 <br/>
 <br/>
 <br/>
ȱȱȱ<br/>
ŗřȱ<br/>
<hr/>
